Total and permanent? 70% of TPD claimants back at work

InsightsArticle18 November 2026

Share this

By Darren Wickham, Head of Group Insurance, Zurich Australia & Kresh Wright, Head of Product & Proposition, Group Insurance, Zurich Australia 


Insurance in super has a problem most Australians have never heard of, and they're paying for it. 

Premiums are rising as claims volumes, particularly for mental health conditions, hit historic levels. 

Ask most insiders and they'll tell you the same thing: Total and Permanent Disability (TPD) cover, in its current form, is no longer fit for purpose.

TPD began as a safety net for the catastrophic illness or injury so severe a person would likely never work again. Its job was always to protect members' retirement savings when their working life was permanently cut short.

It was also affordable. In those early years, insurers priced the product on the assumption that very few people on claim would go back to work given the high threshold required to be classified as being unlikely ever to work again.

But over the years, this changed.

“Unlikely ever” finds new meaning

In 2016, Sunsuper (now Australian Retirement Trust) found 36 per cent of TPD claimants were able to return to some form of work. 

This revelation led to a substantial redesign of TPD insurance by Sunsuper, although not many in the industry followed.

A decade later, in late 2026, Zurich conducted research of its own. We surveyed over two hundred TPD claimants across Australian group and retail insurance products purchased through a variety of insurers and funds.  

The results were stark. 

70 per cent of TPD claimants returned to work at some stage after their claim was accepted. 

Of those who went back to work, 78 per cent did so within 12 months of their claim being accepted, and 77 per cent returned to their previous job in the same or reduced capacity.

The findings were so striking that we repeated the survey. 

The results were almost identical.

Mental health

When TPD was first designed, mental health conditions were not commonly diagnosed or well understood.

When Sunsuper conducted its study a decade ago, 13 per cent of claims were for a mental illness. Zurich’s recent research found that this has more than tripled, with almost half (46 per cent) of successful TPD claimants having a mental-health component to their claim, either as the primary condition or in combination with a physical condition.  

Equally concerning is the fact that two thirds of these mental health claims are in the 18-34 age group. 

The Council of Australian Life Insurers also reports that mental health TPD claims for people in their 30s have risen by more than 700 per cent in the past decade.

The upshot: A product built for permanent disability has evolved to become a temporary income bridge, often for conditions that were not well understood or regularly diagnosed when the products were designed.  

To be clear, most TPD claimants are genuinely unwell or injured and unable to work for a time. But many aren't permanently disabled, and that's not the risk the product was designed or priced for.

Putting a price on permanency   

The cost is borne by every member. Higher default premiums, paid over decades, mean smaller balances at retirement, all to fund a benefit that has become broader than intended.

For some of Australia’s largest super funds, TPD premiums have in some cases doubled or even tripled over the last 10-15 years.

These premiums have increased for a range of reasons: progressive reinterpretation of TPD definitions by courts and complaints bodies, a sharp rise in mental illness claims that are episodic in nature and difficult to assess for permanency, changing claims practices from insurers, changing product terms and evolving consumer expectations, just to name a few.

Where to from here?

This is a turning point, one where trustees and insurers must work together.

This means elevating TPD sustainability from an insurance review issue to a higher strategic trustee priority, balancing adequate protection, affordability and retirement outcomes. This means making conscious choices about the role and size of default cover versus member-selected additional cover.

Insurers should not wait for legislative reform. There is scope to improve policy terms, claims pathways, early intervention, evidence requirements, pricing of voluntary cover and rehabilitation within existing settings. Much of the design work is already done - what's missing is adoption at scale.

We must remove implementation barriers. This means bringing administrators into the process earlier, improving data, and explicitly building delivery capacity into fund change programs. 
It is hard to argue that standing still is in members’ ‘Best Financial Interests’.

Insurance in super is an incredibly important part of Australia’s safety net. Nearly a quarter of people retire early due to a disability or to care for someone with a disability. 

We must all work to preserve this crucial element of our world-class superannuation system.